My friend Christopher Skinner has kindly allowed me to reproduce his review of these two books.
The Jewish New Testament (JNT) and it's companion volume The Jewish New Testament Commentary (JNTC) by David H. Stern is a very valuable work in Messianic circles today. The authors intention is to restore the Jewishness of the New Testament and he has supplied a work which is very much needed. This short review is going to review both positive and critical aspects to this volume.
As an observation, The JNT is not a strictly literal translation and there is nothing wrong with that. Stern informs us that his approach to translation was that of dynamic equivalence. This approach aims to translate the thoughts of the writer rather than a word by word translation. Dynamic equivalence is also used by the NIV, The Message and The Life Application Bible. Those desiring a more literal-grammatical Messianic translation should check out the Hebrew Names Version (HNV) which is authored by a completely different party. The JNT and JNTC assumes knowledge of the Hebrew words and phrases such as Tanakh, Ruach HaKodesh etc which will make it more difficult for some readers, although it is worth doing some homework and receiving the blessing from reading it.
A strength of the JNT and JNTC is it's explanation and specific translation of the words usually translated "Jew" and "Jews". Various passages in standard translations of Johns gospel been used to justify anti-Jewish feeling in religious people. This has given ammunition to critics who charge the New Testament writers with anti-Semitism. In John 5:19, The JNT makes it clear that it is the Judean Jews (and not the Jews as a whole) which harassed Yeshua. The same is the case in his comments on 1 Thessalonians (where it is often dreadfully mistranslated "The Jews, who killed the Lord Jesus"). Stern's discussion of the famous words of the mob "His blood be upon us and upon our children" and Yeshuas prayer "Father forgive them" is both reasonable and sensible. Any believer who wants to stem the tide of theological antisemitism will find these volumes very helpful.
Another good feature of the JNT is the exposition of Pardes, the Rabbinic method of expounding the Tanakh as employed by the New Testament writers. Many standard evangelical commentaries are at a loss to explain apparent misquotes from the Old Testament (such as Matthew 2:15 "out of Egypt I called my Son"). Sterns understanding of first century Jewish interpretation is very helpful to the student of Scripture here. The Jewish context and background of the New Testament is brought out in many ways.
On the critical side, Stern allows his own theological bias to influence the resultant translation and this is evident in some places. This is most evident in his discussions of Torah observance and it's place today. His comments have very practical implications, especially in the areas of observing Intermarriage, Shabbat and Kashrut.
Stern believes that the Law of Moses is still effective and attempts to deal with his "problem passages" but, in my opinion, unconvincingly. My views on the law of Moses concur with that of The Association of Messianic Congregations which states that "The Law of Moses as a rule of life has been fulfilled in the Messiah and therefore believers are no longer under its' obligation or condemnation. While the Law of Moses is no longer obligatory for believers, the Law has much to teach us regarding a joyfully Jewish way of life. Both Jewish and non-Jewish believers have the freedom in Messiah to maintain any aspects of the Law of Moses which do not violate the entirety of the rest of scripture" 1. This clearly shows two different views amongst Messianic believers.
Sterns translation of Romans 10 verse 4 reads that "the goal at which the Torah aims is the Messiah". This brings out a meaning to the passage that fits very well into the wider context of Romans 10, and about the purpose of the Law. The standard versions (eg. NIV, KJV etc) read that "Christ is the END of the Law". Stern states that his translation is a correction of the mainstream versions here. In fairness, I believe both renderings of this verse are correct. The Greek word for "end" is "telos" and it can have both meanings - "goal" and "end". Vine's Expository Dictionary and Vincents New Testament Word Studies give both meanings equal weight, whilst Thayers Greek-English Lexicon gives the primary meaning as "end". Even if the primary meaning was "goal", as Stern believes in relation to this verse, an "end" is implicit as you don't carry on with something once the "goal" has been reached. Stern usually translates "telos" as "end" in numerous places (including Matthew 10:22, John 13:1 and 1 Cor 1:8) but insists that it exclusively means "goal" in Romans 10v4. This translation is favoured in order to preserve the doctrine of Torah observance. There is no reason for making Romans 10:4 an exception to the usual rule, nor is there any reason to restrict the term "telos" exclusively to "goal" in one verse. Stern states that the standard Christian theology based on this verse is anti-semitic but this accusation is extreme and unnecessary. Whilst Stern does a good job in fighting real antisemitism, he occasionally throws the accusation too easily and unfairly.
Overall, the JNT and the JNTC does a good job in achieving it's central aim - restoring the Jewishness of the New Testament. On peripheral matters he expounds the various different points of view before giving his own (and he does so in a way that is humble and not offensive to others who disagree). Such issues as this include the debates over spiritual gifts, eschatology, women in leadership, eternal security and the Calvinist-Arminian controversy. Most readers will probably disagree with some of his views on peripheral matters. The accommodation of different views adds value to a work of this nature as it serves to unite Jewish believers rather than divide. I hope the JNT and JNTC will have wide appeal.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
335 comments:
1 – 200 of 335 Newer› Newest»About David Stern's Bad Translation:
From the Introduction of Stern's Jewish New Testament:
“For example, in other versions the Greek phrase upo nomon is usually translated "under the law". But because this rendering has been used to buttress anti-torah Christian theology, the Jewish New Testament spells out the meaning of these two Greek words in thirteen English words: "in subjection to the system which results from perverting the Torah into legalism." – D. Stern
What is the result of Mr. Sterns new, previously unknown, translation of the term "Law"? His book of Galatians makes Paul into the Hero of the enemy he was (in fact) fighting against!
Let us look at Galatians 2:19.
The REAL New Testament says...
"For I through the Law - under the operations (of the curse) of the Law - have (in Christ's death for me) myself died to the Law and all the Law's demands upon me, so that I may (henceforth) live to and for God." - The Amplified Bible
The false "Jewish New Testament" says...
"For it was through letting the Torah speak for itself that I died to it's traditional legalistic misinterpretation, so that I might live in direct relationship with God."
What's the problem? While Paul clearly says that He is dead to the Torah, Mr. Stern tries to make Paul say that it was only a "misinterpretation" of the Torah which Paul has died to. And the implication which Mr. Stern wants to infer is that Paul (and so, every believer in Jesus) is still under an obligation to obey the "real" Torah.
The entire book of Galatians is distorted and perverted by Mr. Stern's false interpretation and that falsehood can be found throughout Mr. Stern's entire false translation.
generic tramadol online buy tramadol online without script - tramadol 50 mg price street
tramadol online get off tramadol addiction - tramadol hydrochloride 50mg for dogs
tramadol no rx xymel 50mg tramadol hydrochloride - tramadol hcl 25mg dogs
buy lorazepam ativan pregnancy - ativan mg get high
2mg klonopin klonopin withdrawal and insomnia - 2mg klonopin and alcohol
buy tramadol online order tramadol with american express - buy ultram without rx
ativan mg lorazepam qt prolongation - ativan gi side effects
order tramadol online tramadol for dogs cancer - tramadol withdrawal emotional
klonopin klonopin xanax interaction - klonopin helps with anxiety
tramadol no prescription tramadol buying online legal - tramadol generic fedex no prescription
buy tramadol for dogs tramadol hydrochloride 50mg side effects dogs - tramadol 200 mg high
ativan online buy lorazepam mexico - ativan side effects weight
buy tramadol tramadol hcl overdose - tramadol withdrawal codeine
buy cheap tramadol how to purchase tramadol' - where to buy tramadol
tramadol online buy tramadol online safely - tramadol 50 mg a normal dose
buy tramadol overnight buy tramadol in usa - tramadol abuse
can you buy tramadol online legally tramadol online fedex - tramadol hcl tablets 50 mg
best buy tramadol buy tramadol hcl 50 mg - buy tramadol 24x7
buy lorazepam online ativan withdrawal fever - can u buy ativan online
buy tramadol online tramadol urinary retention - ordering ultram online legal
order klonopin online klonopin qtc prolongation - buy clonazepam online canada
ambien online without rx ambien pill price - ambien side effects dry eyes
buy tramadol online purchase of tramadol - tramadol hcl 50 mg for dogs
tramadol online tramadol hcl 200mg er - tramadol generic manufacturers
online ambien ambien side effects aggression - ambien cr order
order clonazepam klonopin high erowid - neurontin klonopin erowid
buy somas soma san diego side stage - soma drug while pregnant
buy ambien online ambien side effects depression - cost of generic ambien cr
best buy tramadol buy tramadol online - buy tramadol next day delivery
tramadol buy tramadol online bluebook - legal order tramadol online
soma online order soma cod - soma to buy online
buy clonazepam online can you buy clonazepam - klonopin withdrawl twitching
ambien online pharmacy generic ambien does look like - ambien india pharmacy
ambien online ambien overdose 20 mg - ambien cr generic brand
buy tramadol free shipping buy tramadol online without a prescription - buy ultram online no rx
order soma online soma san diego enter shikari - soma muscle relaxer and ibuprofen
generic tramadol tramadol online overnight shipping - buy tramadol 24x7
ambien for sale no prescription ambien cr generic a116 - fatal insomnia ambien
tramadol online tramadol ultram for dogs - tramadol for dogs an 627
order klonopin online klonopin with alcohol erowid - klonopin withdrawal chest pain
buy tramadol tramadol 50 mg itching - buy tramadol in florida
purchase tramadol tramadol online apotheke - tramadol 50mg for sale
generic ambien ambien side effects groggy - what does a zolpidem pill look like
buy ambien online overnight pill 74 93 ambien - much does 10 mg ambien sell
tramadol online tramadol xl dosage - tramadol 50 mg o 100 mg
soma online soma triathlon discount code - soma williamsburg
tramadol online buy tramadol online in uk - tramadol hcl generic name
ambien zolpidem much generic ambien - ambien cr online
buy tramadol tramadol 200 mg extended release - tramadol veterinary dosage chart
klonopin anxiety effects of klonopin overdose - klonopin and zoloft for anxiety
cheap tramadol online buy ultram florida - tramadol recreational use bluelight
buy ambien online ambien cr 12.5 half life - ambien online us
order ambien online no prescription whats better sleep ambien xanax - ambien cr versus regular ambien
buy viagra online buy viagra without rx - generic viagra kamagra uk
soma online soma drug label - buy soma tablets
viagra price generic for viagra 100mg - buy viagra online canadian pharmacy
buy tramadol cheap tramadol online fedex - buy tramadol europe
generic ambien buy ambien fast - ambien blue pill
generic ambien how fast does ambien cr work - ambien sold online
buy tramadol tablets tramadol seizures - buy tramadol without prescriptions
purchase ambien order generic ambien online - ambien side effects memory
order viagra online india viagra 50mg dosage - purchase viagra online with prescription
buy soma online soma san diego location - argento soma 01
buy tramadol online tramadol with suboxone - tramadol hydrochloride high
soma online soma bras usa - buy soma boardbag
ambien without prescriptions buy discount ambien - insomnia on ambien
buy viagra for women online viagra sales canada - does viagra work on a full stomach
buy viagra gold viagra discovery - purchase viagra in mexico
generic carisoprodol soma san diego sidestage - order soma from usa
cheap generic ambien drug interactions topamax ambien - price for ambien
buy klonopin online can take klonopin high blood pressure - 2mg klonopin valium
can you buy viagra online legally buy generic viagra online overnight - cheapest place to buy viagra online
where to order viagra certified online pharmacy viagra - legal buy viagra online
order viagra cheap viagra sale online pharmacy - cheap viagra no prescription needed
cheap cialis 20mg buy cialis professional online - cialis online forum
carisoprodol online soma drug test time - is ordering soma online legal
buy soma buy cheap soma no prescription - drug interactions soma flexeril
how to buy cialis online generic cialis quality - buy cialis online uk no prescription
cialis price buy cialis online legal - cialis coupon 30 tablets free
viagra without prescription viagra online canada overnight - generic viagra hoax
soma buy capacity of soma san diego - generic soma imprints
buy viagra pills order viagra legally - order viagra online overnight
order viagra with mastercard best place buy viagra online yahoo answers - order viagra online overnight
buy generic viagra buy viagra ho chi minh - how to buy viagra online forum
sildenafil tablets can u buy viagra uk - generic viagra efficacy
buy tramadol online generic tramadol online - tramadol 50 mg prn
viagra online viagra from india fake - buy viagra online singapore
cialis online cialis online drugs - cialis 5 mg best price
buy viagra online buy viagra uk boots - where to buy generic viagra in uk
tramadol 100 tramadol high grasscity - tramadol 300 mg
buy soma 350mg cheap soma overnight delivery - does soma generic look like
order tadalafil cialis daily sample - buy cialis online fast delivery
buy viagra online cheap viagra quick delivery - viagra online legit
generic tramadol online tramadol hcl 50 mg muscle relaxer - tramadol street value
tramadol without prescription tramadol 50mg reviews - tramadol 50 mg long does stay your system
order viagra online without a prescription buy viagra online cheap canada - online viagra sales canada
buy viagra viagra online canadian - generic viagra quick delivery
cialis pharmacy cialis and nitrates - buy cialis online in usa
buy finasteride propecia reviews before and after - will see results propecia
buy viagra buy viagra online fast delivery - purchase viagra online in india
buy tramadol cheap no prescription tramadol compared to vicodin - buy tramadol online usa
buy viagra online top quality viagra online - buy cheap brand viagra online
cialis online buy cialis online cheapest - cialis daily dose generic
buy propecia online propecia results 3 months - propecia 84
viagra no prescription overnight delivery viagra online usa - illegal to buy viagra online
buy strattera online strattera dosing guide - strattera xr
propecia medication propecia tablets online - propecia tablets online
buy viagra viagra for women fda - buy cheap viagra blog
cialis online generic cialis cheap - buy cialis from canadian pharmacy
purchase propecia propecia side effects kidney - propecia results after 6 months
tramadol online buy tramadol online usa - tramadol dosage acetaminophen
tramadol cheap tramadol 100mg retardtabletten - tramadol shipped with no prescription
buy tramadol rx buy tramadol online florida - tramadol withdrawal in newborns
buy tramadol online tramadol hydrochloride high - buy tramadol online us
generic strattera strattera reviews weight loss - generic strattera 40 mg pills
buy viagra professional buy viagra online uk next day delivery - viagra canada
buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg high - buy tramadol 100mg online
buy tramadol online addiction of tramadol - tramadol overdose much
buy retin a without a prescription retin-a micro usage - retin a cream 0.01
buy strattera online generic equivalent for strattera - strattera side effects usa
buy viagra viagra wiki - viagra for women antidepressants
buy tramadol online tramadol online ireland - tramadol hcl 93
tramadol online tramadol for dogs or people - tramadol online credit card
order tramadol online tramadol dosage slow release - ultram side effects rash
cialis online buy cialis daily use - buy cialis mumbai
buy tramadol online tramadol hcl 10 mg - cheap tramadol online overnight delivery
tramadol online overnight tramadol buying online legal - buy tramadol in usa
tramadol online nebenwirkungen von tramadol 100mg - buy tramadol online 100mg
tramadol buy buy tramadol visa - where to buy tramadol online
tramadol generic buy 200 mg tramadol online - tramadol dosage acetaminophen
buy tramadol buy tramadol online fedex delivery - tramadol dosage restless leg syndrome
buy tramadol online buy tramadol cod fedex - tramadol hcl 37.5 mg
buy tramadol online where to buy tramadol online usa - tramadol dosage per day
tramadol 50 mg buy tramadol online 100mg - tramadol used withdrawal
generic strattera where can i buy strattera online - strattera growth
buy tramadol no prescription tramadol 50 mg with alcohol - why can you buy tramadol online
buy tramadol online cod tramadol online overnight mastercard - tramadol er dosage
can you buy tramadol online tramadol 50 mg safe - buy tramadol legal
tramadol 100mg cheap tramadol canada - tramadol hcl
buy retin-a retin-a micro safe - retin a acne initial breakout
buy tramadol online no prescription tramadol generic manufacturers - is tramadol for dogs a narcotic
tramadol 50 mg tramadol high lasts - tramadol overdose can kill
tramadol no prescription tramadol addiction during pregnancy - tramadol stada 100mg nebenwirkungen
buy tramadol tramadol xl - tramadol dosage small dogs
propecia online pharmacy propecia side effects premature ejaculation - generic propecia safety
tramadol 50mg tramadol with acetaminophen dosage - tramadol for dogs versus humans
buy tramadol online with mastercard get off tramadol addiction - order tramadol online sweden
tramadol 50mg tramadol pills - tramadol hcl 50 mg for migraines
buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription usa - buy tramadol 50mg
tramadol 50 mg tramadol hcl 50 mg pill identifier - tramadol withdrawal percocet
buy tramadol cheap tramadol overnight shipping - tramadol hcl mg tablet
propecia without prescription propecia generic patent expiration - propecia the crack ho
buy strattera maximum strattera dosing - strattera medication dosage
tramadol 50mg tramadol online no prescription overnight delivery - tramadol hcl back pain
buy tramadol tramadol hcl side effects humans - good site buy tramadol
buy tramadol overnight shipping tramadol medication purchase - tramadol renal dosing
buy propecia best quality generic propecia - propecia results regrowth
buy tramadol without rx tramadol overdose yahoo answers - is it illegal to purchase tramadol online
buy tramadol mastercard symptoms of tramadol addiction - tramadol addiction withdrawal
cheap tramadol online tramadol hydrochloride 100mg used - buy tramadol echeck
tramadol no prescription tramadol ultram ingredients - get tramadol online
best buy tramadol tramadolor 100 mg - tramadol hcl 50mg 627
tramadol 50 mg tramadol pregnancy - tramadol quinine
buy generic tramadol buy tramadol in florida - is tramadol/ultram an opiate
cheap tramadol online tramadol online cod - tramadol online pharmacy usa
tramadol generic tramadol hcl dogs dosage - tramadol for dogs for sale
tramadol online tramadol hcl 50 mg tablet - tramadol 50 mg extended release
viagra online without prescription viagra buy in usa - cheap generic viagra online review
tramadol 50 mg tramadol for dogs empty stomach - tramadol hcl paracetamol tablets
buy tramadol reliable online pharmacy tramadol - buy tramadol no prescription overnight
cheap viagra buy brand viagra no prescription - buy generic viagra cialis
viagra online without prescription buy-generic viagra reviews - viagra online pharmacy europe
generic viagra viagra for women in chennai - yahoo answer viagra online
viagra online without prescription order viagra fast - viagra online fast delivery
buy cialis cialis free sample coupon - cialis 5mg reviews
generic viagra non generic viagra online - buy viagra in us
buy tramadol order tramadol cod - order tramadol by phone
viagra online without prescription generic viagra in stores - generic viagra online us
buy cheap viagra buy generic viagra online overnight - viagra for women price in us
generic cialis cialis reviews comments - where to buy cialis canada
buy tramadol buy ultram online canada - tramadol for purchase
tadalafil 20mg buy cialis online in canada - cialis free printable coupon
purchase viagra order viagra line - cheap viagra pills australia
buy cialis can you buy cialis over the counter in america - cialis online overnight
buy tramadol buy tramadol lowest price - tramadol 50mg what is it for
sildenafil citrate buy cheap viagra online us - viagra going generic
generic viagra generic viagra us paypal - viagra dosage with food
viagra online without prescription buy genuine viagra online us - buy viagra online new york
buy tramadol buy generic tramadol no prescription - order tramadol online cod
generic viagra buy viagra no prescription needed - buy viagra online us
tadalafil online generic cialis shipped to canada - can i buy cialis over the counter in canada
viagra 100mg viagra walmart - online prescription viagra buy online
viagra online without prescription order viagra online forum - cheap viagra cialis online
generic viagra viagra 30 - buy original viagra us
cheap viagra buy viagra from us online - viagra 70 years plus men
cheap cialis buy cialis kl - cialis 20 mg cost
generic viagra is generic viagra legal in united states - buy viagra us tesco
viagra online without prescription viagra online store us - cheap viagra levitra
cheap viagra viagra online discover card - generic viagra online pharmacy us
Post a Comment